Our Store

storepic1storepic2Welcome to Basically Buttercream and Cafe.  Join us for some great food and dive into some of our various pastries.  Included in the store are the Basically Meals To Go which are ready to cook meals for you and your family.  These include a variety of our hot menu items.

Looking for a wedding, birthday or specialty cake?  Stop in and see Shannon or call for a scheduled appointment.


Tues – Fri: 10 am –  7 pm
Sat: 8 am – 4 pm
Sun – Mon: Closed

 Check out our Menu

Stop In and See Us Today! We have daily specials and chef sandwich choices that vary daily \ weekly along with the following as our main menu of salads, sandwiches.  We have several daily cupcake flavors to choose from as well as other sweets!


Rocket Arugula Salad – Spring radishes, cucumbers, feta and cilantro ginger vinaigrette – Full 8, Petite 6

The Chopped Cobb – Confit of Amish chicken, local bacon, shell cooked egg, tomato and cheddar cheese – Full 10, Petite 7

Traditional Caesars Salad – Romaine, house made Caesar dressing, Shannon’s sweet garlic crostini, parmesan – Full 7, Petite 5

Spinach Salad – Roasted portabella mushrooms, caramelized red onions, shell cooked egg, blistered tomatoes – Full 9, Petite 5

Traditional Farm Salad – crisp romaine, shredded carrot, red onion, cucumber, cherry tomato, cottons, and cheddar cheese – Full 7, Petite 5

Sandwiches, Includes one side
(side salad and seasonal side $1 extra)

Brownsburg Press – Pork shoulder, cheddar cheese, pickles and Sweet Baby Ray’s, pressed on a French style hoagie – 8

Brisket Press – Mesquite smoked Fishers Farms brisket, horsey sauce or BBQ, cheddar cheese or swiss on artisan bread – 10

Cuban Press – Citrus and cilantro slow cooked Fischer Farm pork shoulder, swiss cheese, pickles, Fischer Farms smoked ham and mustard – 10

Ultimate Grilled Cheese – Provolone, fresh mozzarella and aged cheddar on artisan bread – 7 w\Ham or Turkey 10

BLT with an A – Fischer Farms nitrate free bacon, beefsteak tomato, leaf lettuce and avocado with mayonnaise on artisan bread – 8

Amish Chicken Salad – Confit free range chicken with celery, onion and mayo on an artisan bread – 8


1/2 Salad and Soup – 9

1/2 Sammie and Soup – 10

1/2 Sammie and Salad – 12

Add a protein to the above salads – Chicken 3, Salmon 7


Kale Chips – 3

Potato Chips – 3

Fresh Fruit – 3

Side Salad – 4

Seasonal Side – 4